Bharati Mukherjee Books
Related Subjects:
More Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

This book, I have to say, was The best book I have ever readReview Date: 1999-04-17

Look Below the SurfaceReview Date: 2005-04-21
This book spoke to me not only as a woman, but also as a young adult, who is on her way into a life unkown, much like Hannah and Beigh. I highly recommend this book to any reader who is looking for a smart and exciting journey into another world.
Fails to EntertainReview Date: 2005-04-28
The problem is in the style of the writing. Although the book is very well researched and informed, the narrative is stiff and dull. The dialogue seems trite and unrealistic, however little there was. The story had an interesting premise, time travel and fantasy projection, but it failed to deliver the goods in that area. One almost thinks that that author should have left that out completely or commit to it whole heartedly.
On a positive note, the novel does manage to produce a few truly interesting characters and works well as a feminist novel, mostly dealing with symbolism of female emancipation. The author also hinted at the possibility of a high adventure story but cut that off quickly with spare, stale action.
I gave this novel two stars because of the intelligence of language only. But there is a big difference between that and being able to produce a concise, tight novel that tells a story well and commits to it.
This book will not let you down.Review Date: 2006-11-08
I can't describe how much I love this book. The ending is phenomenal, ingenious, genre bending stuff. Totally unexpected and deservedly earns to me the bestowed crown of reviews: one of the best endings of any book I have ever read. The prose is thick, it is not a quick read, but this is a detail oriented book. It is very smartly written, and I would recommend it to any professor looking for a great multicultural studies course novel. The romance of the book is sweeping but also restrained. Mukherjee is an expert at making us patiently wait for a deserved outcome. I can't say any more without giving too much away. Holder of the World is a huge accomplishment of a novel, it is something utterly unique in the number of directions it takes and the number of places we go in it makes us realize that love, however brief, is truly the greatest treasure.
A Luminous Gem Of A NovelReview Date: 2004-12-18
Beigh Masters is a woman who "lives in three time zones simultaneously." Not Eastern, Central and Pacific Time, but "the past, the present and the future." Her Yale thesis on the Puritans led her to graduate school, and to a figure from the distant past, an ancestor, actually. At grad school she met and began her life with her lover, Venn Iyer. She also began her career as an "asset-hunter," a detective of sorts, who seeks out antiques and other priceless items for wealthy clients. Venn, born and raised in India, and a graduate of MIT, "animates information." He and his team are somehow recreating the universe by the mass ingestion of the entire world's information: newspapers, records and documents, telephone directories, satellite passes, every TV and radio show aired, political debate, airline schedule - well, just about every piece of information ever recorded. When the grid, the base, is complete, they hope to insert a person into time and space through this careful reconstruction of the past by the meticulous build-up of data.
Beigh has a client who hired her to track down the most perfect diamond in the world - "The Emperor's Tear." She has also been searching for a woman, known as Salem Bibi, who lived over 300 years ago. Beigh knows more about Hannah Easton, called Salem Bibi, than perhaps anyone who ever lived, and through her knowledge of this woman, she comes closer to finding the Emperor's Tear." Hannah, born into Puritan society in Massachusetts in 1670, orphaned at an early age because of fierce Indian attacks on her settlement, married an English trader/adventurer/pirate. She traveled with him to England, and then to Mughal India, at the time of the establishment of the British East India Company. There Hannah became the lover of a Hindu raja and took-on the name Salem Bibi. She is the last known person to have seen and held the "Emperor's Tear." She is also an ancestor of Beigh Masters.'
"The Holder of the World" is both Hannah's and Beigh's story. And they are both remarkable women. Hannah lived centuries ahead of her time. She was born into the restricted Puritan world, in a new country with few amenities and much hardship. The New World was a dangerous and alien environment where women knew their place. Hannah, however, was an inquisitive, lively, vital woman, with a knowledge of self and a sense of purpose. She perhaps inherited her spirited nature from her mother, a woman whose terrible secret Hannah kept all her life.
This is a beautifully written, complex novel of history, ideas and adventure. Bharati Mukherjee vividly creates a tale of relocation, the collision of values, transformation and the courage it takes to adapt to new cultures. And here two worlds do meet...and collide - the Puritan American and the Mughal Indian. Hannah guides Beigh, who in turn steers the reader through the centuries to solve ancient mysteries. I would have liked to have felt closer to Hannah. However, the author always seems to keep her at a distance, as a historic figure. I do recommend this novel as it is unusual and makes for excellent reading.
JANA
Virtual history: being thereReview Date: 2002-02-16
But there is more: the novel is so brilliantly themed, the premise so unique, that this reader was guided through a journey of staggering originality. Beigh's lover/companion, Venn, is developing a computer program that would allow an individual to experience a few moments in the past, set to a specific time frame, with pertinent information entered into the program. Beigh provides the structural facts, creating the opportunity to ......? Is it really even possible? This is not "time-travel" as usually written, but Virtual participation in real time. Mukerjee actually ties the threads of history together, from one side of the world to the other, suggesting infinite permutations. Not your traditional historical novel, Mukerjee fashions an ending worthy of any mystery-adventure devotee. Experiencing this story is an adventure in itself.
Used price: $1.91

RebuttalReview Date: 2006-09-04
While this is sometimes a shocking book, only the severely culture-bound and those with no sense of humour will find it boring. I would rate it as an update on Kafka's 'Amerika' - a modern vision of the USA by the latest underclass of arrivals, struggling to carve out their identity in the land of [for them] little peace and [frequently] not much glory. It'll make you laugh and cry - but you'll never see yourself as others see you unless you try .
Peter's reviewReview Date: 2005-09-14
A very good book for indians in America!!Review Date: 2002-02-24
An Excellent Collection of Diverse StoriesReview Date: 2005-09-08
But what makes this collection so special is that Ms. Mukherjee does not focus on her Indian roots, though several stories do concern people of Indian heritage, but cover many diverse cultures -- Italian- Americans, An Iraqi Jew, a Vietnam veteran in Florida and express a wide range of "voices." These stories are particularly effective in that you find yourself involved in the characters and their circumstances almost instantly. It is as if you had prior knowledge of them as you begin to read any one of the stories.
She also has a literary "trick" of sorts that I really enjoyed in that she will make reference to some little item --almost as a throwaway that was featured in an earlier story in the collection. It is very subtle but a nice little device that I caught on to and served to enhance the experience even more.
And though this collection was published sometime ago I found these wonderful stories still timely. I would highly recommend this collection to anyone who enjoys this genre.
Now on to purchase soem of her other works.
BEST INDIAN WRITER BY FARReview Date: 2002-02-14

Used price: $0.58
Collectible price: $31.95

Needed a "This is a sequel" designation on the coverReview Date: 2008-04-20
I'd even go with 3.5 stars -- though perhaps I would have enjoyed it more and ranked it higher if I'd known this was a sequel prior to reading it. I have ordered the first book "Desirable Daughters" and hope that "Tree Bride" comes together more fully after I've read the first installment.
Nothing on my hardback copy of "Tree Bride" indicated it is a sequel -- QUITE disappointing and, as it turned out, it lessened my appreciation of this book quite a bit.
Well-written, definitely -- Ms. Mukherjee is a talented writer. It just seemed disjointed and, I thought, could have benefited greatly from inclusion of a family tree. Perhaps with the first book as background I might not have needed a family tree -- I do not yet know.
A Memorable StoryReview Date: 2007-03-17
This book is second in a trilogy (first was "Desirable Daughters). I look forward to experiencing the third.
felt like I walked in in the middleReview Date: 2005-08-23
And now that I know this was part of a trilogy, I am looking forward to reading "Desirable Daughters" and the third book.
VERY confusing and hard to followReview Date: 2005-04-20
Wow! Great Book!Review Date: 2004-09-08

THE FACTSReview Date: 2002-02-25

Used price: $7.94

Great, great book!Review Date: 2008-01-04
Review of JasmineReview Date: 2005-05-18
The story deals with Jasmine trying to deal with the past in order to move on with the future. She has trouble dealing with her past because she has survived so many traumatic situations in her life. She also does not know how to do deal with the past and tends to carry it along with her.
Mukherjee had great themes throughout the story. I found that one of the themes was finding your true identity in a chaotic world. Jasmine goes through many names throughout the story including Jyoti, Jazzy, Jane, and Jase. Her life becomes very chaotic because she has to go from place to place trying to find out who she wants to be in the American world. Another theme that I found intriguing was that we are never satisfied with what we have. Throughout this story Jasmine always wants more. She wants the American lifestyle and in the end we see that. She has the right to choose Bud who she will have a laid back lifestyle and many people believe that he represents the Indian culture or she can choose Taylor who will give her an adventurous lifestyle. She has to choose whether she is happy with what she has with Bud or does she want more.
I enjoyed the story overall because she caught my attention with her vivid descriptions in her scenes. The one scene that always sticks out in my mind is when she compares the room where she murdered her rapist to a slaughter house. She used great vivid details to describe the stabbing.
Compulsively readable!Review Date: 2006-05-30
Jasmine is faced with much turmoil and many choices, none of which are easy. Her life is far from conventional, but it says volumes about what it must be like to forge a new life in a new place with an identity that even she is not certain of.
I found that the ending was a little abrupt, but other than this, I have no complaints. Mukherjee is a vivid and serious writer, one who will leave you with an often times visceral reaction.
Warning: I have heard some complaints about the beginning chapters being mildly confusing concerning character introductions, but I assure you, if you stick with it, what she is doing will become clear quite quickly. This author's technique of introducing characters is very unique and effective and gives the reader a real sense of time without being exactly linear.
freedom vs. dutyReview Date: 2005-05-18
Mukherjee's style of writing is unique and difficult to grasp at first. She would refer back to the past or fast forward into the present periodically so the reader must constantly `be on their toes.' She leaves `cliffhangers' at the end of paragraphs or chapters that are reunited with their explanations of what would happen in later chapters. Mukherjee would leave her readers in curiosity as she skips around in her time machine within her story.
Mukherjee wrote eloquently as she weaved Jasmine's various identities into one novel. Jasmine, who is also Jyoti, Jazzy, Jase and Jane, is faced between clinging to her `feudalistic traditions' or her `new western-thinking traditions.' Each identity of hers represents a new lifestyle and a new challenge that she must conquer. She experiences a sense of two sides inside her, each competing to grasp the fullness of her whole body and soul.
Jasmine was torn between assimilating into American freedom and society vs. being bound to her deep-rooted traditions. Characters within the novel assist the protagonist in her journey as she tries to battle her fate and destiny. Overall, the book was well written and packed with a journey between Jasmine's duty as an Indian woman and freedom that she desires in America.
Powerful and honestReview Date: 2005-07-23
Jasmine is a novel I would recommend to anyone, it is so beautiful (some of the quotes I have memorized, even!) I didn't ever want it to end... and it unfortunately takes only a couple hours to read!
The story is of a woman who starts out in a very small village in India and eventually is married to a progressive Indian man who convinces her to think for herself and break away from the feudal ideals that make her think she must be nothing but a subservient baby maker/house keeper. Her husband is murdered early in their marriage and Jasmine, who is turning into a real fighter, makes a terrible and unforgettable trip to America to honor her husband's memory. The rest is history as Jamine finds her way and searches personal fulfillment and self-actualization... she becomes to some extent assimilated in this process, though she always carries her past along with her.
And I can attest to the fact that it is not simply a women's novel: my boyfriend and I read this together and he fell in love with the book too!
Used price: $0.45

DarknessReview Date: 2005-05-11
If Mukherjee were Nabokov, the introduction to this novel would be a trick, a game, something to deceive our reading of the stories to come. Unfortunately, this was not the case. Perhaps I am simply too young to understand the politics surrounding this book's publication, perhaps things have changed, but the rah-rah-USA-nation-of-immigrants vs. o-racist-Canada opposition really irked me throughout the book. (And I am from the US.) Frankly, this collection read to me like it was being written with a certain purpose for a certain group of people, whether intentionally or (much, much worse and less forgivable) unintentionally.
I was most surprised that one reviewer wrote that he enjoyed and understood "Darkness" because, as an Asian man, he can understand such a thing. As someone who thought this book would mainly be enjoyed by enlightened white folk in search of clues to Indian-American cultural identity and pathos, I was certainly shocked especially that someone would proudly claim his affinity to a character I read as weak and emasculated by the strong women close to him, momentarily relieved that some man might have had temporary power over his daughter, terrified to the point of murder when he realized his mistake.
In short (which I haven't been), I was disappointed in the stories, annoyed by some of the unnatural moments in Mukherjee's writing when it is clear she is too aware of her audience and not living deeply within her characters (What Indian person would say "Goa, India" for example, rather than just the obvious "Goa"), HOWEVER, given the other reviewer's easy identification with the characters-- I may be completely off in my charactertization of these stories.
4 StarsReview Date: 1999-11-27
DarknessReview Date: 2000-04-03
Collectible price: $25.00

Home and the WorldReview Date: 2002-03-10
Blaise and Mukherjee met at a writers workshop in Iowa, married, and lived in Canada with their two children until their house burned down which left them homeless and prompted their journey east. Mukherjee spent her formative years in Calcutta and is returning to a largely familiar world but to Blaise everything is new. The first sixty pages of his narrative take place in Bombay and Blaise is never altogether at home there as they are staying with Mukherjees parents and her father is the uncontested head of the household. Blaise's trips into the city are flights from the congestion of stifling family life, his insights into the nature of Indian family life are in equal parts humorous and informative(the family does not even know the first name of a servant who has lived with them for years, nor do they show any interest in knowing). This view of India from an outsider given an insiders access is just one of many aspects of this book that distinguishes it from mere travel narrative. His initiation into the rituals and customs and (to him)peculiarites of Indian family life make for great reading. But the best section is the sustained amazement and energy of the 10-15 page description of Calcutta(where they have chosen to spend the better part of the year in a mission which caters to scholars) as he rides a rickshaw through its cluttered streets. Over the course of the year Blaise will meet many of Calcutta's elite including its most famous(to the west anyway)citizen, the film maker Satyajit Ray. Calcutta is the major city of Bengal, the eastern most province of India, filled with a proud and cultured people, and Blaise spends many fascinating pages analyzing both its culture and polotics:
The Bengali has lived with the English longer than any Indian, and he has absorbed him,while keeping his own soul, with astounding ease. -p.122
Blaise begins with illusions about India but over the course of his year in Calcutta he learns about its culture and people and the contact with this world different in every imaginable way from his own has a profound impact on him, the way he views the west, and the way he views his marriage.
In counterpoint to Blaise's description of the year is Mukherjee's. She is a westernised Indian who has married outside,and according to her father beneath,her caste and in caste conscious India that is often an unforgivable offense. The Mukherjee girls(Bharati and her sisters)are brilliant and Bharati is beautiful and her novel, The Tigers Daughter, just published to rave reviews, has made her famous in her home country. Her year is marked by equally profound realizations which include increased self awareness of her own very personal way of blending if not bridging the two very distinct cultures of which she is a part:
My aesthetic, then, must accomadate a decidedly Hindu imagination with an Americanized sense of the craft of fiction. To admit to possessing a Hindu imagination is to admit that my concepts of what constitutes a "story" and of narrative structure are noncausal, non-Western.-p.298
But perhaps the most fascinating part of her section is her portrait of her former classmates who have stayed in India and married and now make up the elite. These highly educated women are nonetheless stranded in their homes and live cloistered social lives atop an India which has grown restless and intolerant of the wide divisions that separate the rich from the poor. Riots and robbery are always imminent realities. The women Mukherjee observes clothed in silk saris and gold bracelets and diamond earings in their gated community of mansions in the worlds poorest city seem trapped in a world that they know cannot last. They go on as if immune(or wishing to be) from all the realites around them, a social elite with money to burn but drained of contact and significance to the greater India outside their own very high walls.
Rare book by two excellent writers & one that has not gone through too many reprintings so get a copy while you can. I especially like the sturdy(always good for a travel book) '95 Hungry Mind paperback edition with excellent cover art as well as updated prologues and epilogues by the authors.
Half of Book lacks DIRECTION and INTEREST!!!!Review Date: 2004-04-13
If Mukherjee had written this book entirely, readers' interest may not have wandered as far. Bharati's interpretation of their journey is nostalgic and whimsical at the same time, telling of her return to India after a fourteen-year absence. She often visites the idea of what if; for example, what if she'd stayed behind in India and married an Indian? What if she'd led the traditional Indian life?
I feel a bit sorry for her story being the secondary plot in this otherwise difficult book.
Used price: $0.65

Desirable DaughtersReview Date: 2007-10-27
Desirable DaughtersReview Date: 2005-08-16
An unworthy readReview Date: 2006-09-18
The plot left much to be desired, and was hard to follow at times. There seemed to be no clear resolution to any conflict and random ideas were thrown in haprazordly. However, the description of Bengali life and social status was portrayed accurately and some characters(such as Rabi, the narrators son, was three dimensional). All in all, I could have found a much better book to read on a lazy Sunday afternoon- Dont waste your time on this novel.
Not very captivating at allReview Date: 2006-08-19
Canon reformation fadReview Date: 2006-02-16
Rather than letting the quality of the writing do the talking Mukherjee infuses her tedious prose with cliched cultural references and overblown reinterpretation. Leaves the reader feeling quite angry at how an author could be so presumptuous.

A complex protagonistReview Date: 2000-05-28
Related Subjects:
More Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9